Migration: THE POT NEVER MELTS (Satis Shroff)
THE POT NEVER MELTS I
(Satis Shroff)
ONCE upon a time in a
country sandwiched between two great ponds: the Atlantic and the
Pacific, there was a big nation of migrants who called themselves
Americans. Since the country was ravishingly beautiful but wild, and
without infrastructures, millions of people from Europe were invited
to create a new white society. They constructed a melting pot theory
in which all Europeans (later other earth dwellers too) were to be
put in the pot. The melting pot revolutionized the foreigners who
entered the melting pot, which carried the name: the United States of
America. The motley foreigners were expected to be easily dissolved.
They could also be dissolved into tears because the very idea was
against human nature.
People from diverse
nations were expected to set up an American civilization together.
That was the path (The Road Not Taken, Robert Frost, 1916) America
had chosen. The Native Americans had no other choice but to subdue
and be a part of American history. They were swept by the great
migratory current from the Atlantic Ocean, which brought European
settlers eager to eke out a new living in the west. They conquered
the wilderness and its natives to become colonial masters and give a
characteristic shpe to the history of Canada, USA and South America.
It might be noted that the map of Europe, with its different nations,
was also a product of many migrations in the continent.
I met the American writer
Ishmael Reed at the Freiburger University's Peterhof cellar, Niemen
Strasse 10, for the second time. He was in Freiburg in 1992 with a
group of American writers who came formerly from South Asian,
Afro-American and Hispanic backgrounds, that is, multicultural
authors belonging to the US mainstream out to do 'a striptease of the
soul' as one writer put it. Among the writers were: Clark Blaise, a
French-Canadian writer married to Bharati Mukerjee, a writer and NY
socialite of Indian descent. Then there was J.A. Phillips who wrote
about American and Caribbean culture. Ishmael Reed was then
associated with new vodooism and was billed as a humorous writer.
Today, Reed is together
with Toni Morrison, one of the pre-eminent African American literary
figures, most widely rev ewed since Ralph Ellison, and also just as
controversial as Samuel Delany and the late Amiri Baraka.
Ishmail Reed said: ' I
used to be a discipliine problem, which caused me embarrasment until
I realized that being a discipline problem in a racist society is
sometimes an honour.'
Reed's first novel was
'The Free-Lance Pallbearers (1967) and so far he has written seven
novels, four books of poetry, two collections of essays and numerous
reviews. His works are multicultural, revolutionary, vivid and
contain a deep awareness of mythic archetypes.
Freedom from social,
political and religious repression was the cause of migration of
people from Egypt to the days of the sailing ships like the
'Mayflower' and the flight of the Hugenotts from a France which was
ruled by Ludwig XIV to England, as well as the migration of Jews from
Hitler's Third Reich. Then came the Korean and Viernam wars, followed
by the Balkan War (Sebrenica), the conflicts in the Hindukush
(Afghanistan) in which the Soviets were involved first, and later the
USA, the war in Iraq culminating in the bombardment of Syria.
In the two wars in
Afghanistan and Iraq alone 250,000 people were killed. In Afghanistan
the Tabibans are at the moment about to take over the power. Osama
bin Laden was killed in Abbottabad (Pakistan) by the US Seals. Cuba
wants Guantanamo back together with financial compensation. If it
hadn't been for China, the USA would have experienced a financial
collapse in 2008 during the Lehmann-crisis. The IS terror is
spreading like a Prarie wildfire in Africa and Syria. The USA has
lost its power and influence as a world policeman. Putin's Russia has
annexed Crimea. The Ukranians are gradually receiving military
assistance from the reluctant US and Nato countries.
Myth of Racism: All
humans,whether from the northern or southern hemisphere, have the
same physical traits and there are no pure racial types. It is
interesting to note that ethnologically speaking, all existing races
have been fairly thoroughly mixed. Races don't have psychological
innate traits. Hiitler's theory of a superior ryan race has long been
declared as unscientific by anthropologists and medical scientists.
People look different due to their situation over time and
environment, and not to anything inborn. Variations in the colour of
hair, skin and eyes are due to differences in the amount of the dark
pigment melanin, which even causes the blueness of the eyes, when
overlain with unpigmented tissues which diffract light.
Racial and social
barriers have broken with globalisation. In Brasil, almost half of
the genes in the Black population group are of European origin, and
in the Americans of African origin the proportion is a quarter.
Racism, the octrine that
one race is inherently superior or inferior to others, is a myth and
is the cause of racial prejudice, and is a vulgar superstition
believed by the eternally ignorant colonialists and their kind.
Education enlightens, and is the only answer to such atrocious,
inhuman behaviour and line of thinking.
The Melting Pot, Salad
Bowl, US Mosaic, American Pizza, Cultural Pluralism: It is a fact
that the US has been, and still is, a country dominated by the
whites. In 1776 the founding fathers of the USA chose the motto: 'E
pluribus unum.' Out of many, one. These words were to be on the seal
of the United States of America, a union of former colonies, the
amalgamation of a new nation, thanks to the European enlightenment.
In the Declaration of Independence were the words 'All men are
created equal' but men in those days meant 'whites only.' Native
Americans, Inuiits and African Americans were excluded from this
exalted deal.
It was Dr. Martin Luther
King, who led civil rights demonstrators, who made their way from
Selma to Montgomery on March 22, 1965 in Alabama, who showed moral
courage and the non-violent method practiced against the British Raj
by Mahatma Gandhi in India, that paved the way for better rights of
the underdogs of the American society. The African Americans showed
respect for American law and democracy on this day. It was ironical
to witness this in a nation built on slave labour after hundreds of
years of oppression at the hands of the white mainstream. King
finished his speech with the words of the movement's anthem: 'we
shall overcome.' When he was finally allowed to cross the Edmund
Pettus Bridge and made his way to Montgomery with his tired marchers,
he said: 'The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends towards
justice.' In the aftermath of the injustice and racial-tageted
problems in Ferguson, it is hoped that justice will be meted out
correctly.
On the other hand, the
two million Native American Indians and Inuit people in the USA have
had more autonomy, and have had it longer, than their Canadian or
Latin American counterparts. Although the US Supreme Court declared
that the tribes were 'domestic dependent nations in 1831, that status
was largely fiction. Self-government without developpmmennt gave the
Native Americans the responsibility to administer their own poverty.
Native Americans have the shortest life-spans, highest infant
mortality rate, highest school dropout rate and enormous problems
than any ethnic group in the USA.
As people and cultures
evollve they become more and more distinctive, and diversity works as
a functon of social evolution. Unity in diversity is what we all
strive for in the name of progress and mutual protection. Making and
taking the best out of the uniqueness of the diverse population of a
nation, and turning it to a blessing by using the people's unique
talents and abilities is the future of the USA, UK, European Union
and other nations with democracy as its leitmotif. As Crevecoeur
observed in 1782, in America 'individuals of all nations are melted
into a new American race.' Scott London rightly looks upon the
hybridization of America as ' a source of great promise.' According
to him, the future belongs to the mestizo: the person who straddles
many different worlds and can help explain them to each other.
America reinvents itself.
It uses the alchemy of the melting pot and turns 'them' into 'us.'
The secret? Motion, dynamics, new genetic combinations, traditions,
rituals, communal living, absorption into the American society's
different layers. The story of the melting pot is one of earthly
redemption with people from all over the world taking part in the
American Dream, each according to his or her talent and
qualification. Despite the fact that millions of strangers from all
continents brought their contradictory genes and temperaments into
the melting pot, what came out in the end was a polyglot melange that
functioned well. There was kinetic energy gathering to mould a
nation, as it had done throughout the past.
Meanwhile, the melting
pot theory wasn't working and new models came: the Salad Bowl,
American Mosaic, American Pizza and Cultural Pluralism. While
Anglo-Saxon Protestants (WASPS) still run the mainstream but many
citizens from the Salad Bowl are successful and respected society
members and future actors in the US political scenario. True
multiculturalism still hasn't reached the hearts and mind of the
people. 'Yes we can,' said President Obama.
Immigration causes also a
brain drain in terms of well-trained professionals from industrially
underdeveloped countries who leave for the USA or Europe in search of
better jobs and living standards. The wage difference between the USA
and its neighbour Mexico alone is 15 to 1. The risk of poverty in the
USA is part of the bargain, whether the motivation is political or
economic repression. What about Americans or Europeans? The pioneer
days are long over and there's no redistribution of talent. Americans
trickle to developing countries as peace corps and volunteers of
other NGOs. The impact is minimal in comparison to the brain drain to
the Europe or the USA, Canada, Australia and New Zealand.
* * *
THE
POT NEVER MELTS II (Satis Shroff)
Like in the
UK, the second generation children of migrants who grew up in the USA
were self-conscious about their acquired American status and refused
to speak the native language of their parents. They married outside
the ethnic groups, moved out of ethnic ghettos where their parents
felt safe, and Americanized themselves. They believed in the melting
pot theory of American culture. The ethnic ingredients didn't melt
and remained separate, like islands of individual entities. Wearing
American apparels and putting on a pseudo-American accent only hlped
change their public image but in their inner world they hadn't become
Americans.
Today,the
fourth and fifth generation Americans are proud of their heritage as
Indo-Americans, German-American, Russian-Americans and
Asian-Americans, and are loyal, true-to-the-heart US citizens. There
are more than 38 million foreign-born residents in the USA, which
makes 12 per cent of the population.
In the UK
the Ukip Party has made the run with the immigrant debate in the past
years, and even conservative and labour parties opted for a garder
line on migrants. Britain is actually a globalised country with a
huge, hardworking, mobile electorate born abroad in its former
colonies. Such British citizens find this kiind of rhetoric awfully
alienating. According to a report, the country that provides the most
foreign-born voters in England and Wales is India, followed by
Pakistan, the Irish republic and Bangladesh. The message that
migrants are an equal and valued part of 21st
century Britain is still not evident.
The
Caribbean migrants arrived in Tilbury Docks (UK) in 1948, many of
them Jamaican veterans of World War II, the London Evening Standard
ran a headline: 'Welcome Home.' But the welcome was hastily erased
later in the inappropriate move to slam the open door in Britain.
Caribbeans recruited as British citizens to help solve the post-war
labour shortage were soon disabused. Nevertheless, it is heartening
to note that their largely British-born children have assumed a
steadily growing prominence in many sectors of British life. Writer
Caryl Phillips' debut novel 'The Final Passage' paid his tribute to
his parents# generation of West Indians who came to England in the
fifties in search of a better life in the motherland of the English
language. In his travel book 'The European Tribe' (1987) he spoke for
his generation who were black and British, and the 'subtle and
unsubtle ways that I did not belong.'
However, in
the long run it is hoped that democracy in western countries (USA,
UK, Germany and Europe in general) can help to bridge the gap and
allow us to live more peaceably.
After 9/11
and the threat of Islamic States (IS), Americans alternate between
hospitality and paranoia, much like Germans with the influx of
refugees from war-torn countries like Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria and
even peaceful Balkan countries such as Albania, Madedonia and Kosovo.
In Germany the neonazis, old nazis and the pegida movement centered
around Dresden want to have a white race Germany and has angst of a
Moslem majority in the hoary future. In Germany, the trauma of World
War II is long over, and the country has become prosperous, thanks to
the US Care-Packets, the Marshal Plan and the Wirtschaftwunder in the
fifties. The Berlin Wall has falled and the Germans in the West were
obliged to to help build the former East Germany, which had been
ruined by the communists, by means of a compulsory fund. The job is
done, but Germany population is getting old and needs young peopple
to finance and guarantee the pensions, medical tabs and other
gerontological bills of the elerl generation.
Germany,
like America, offered a prize to workers from the poorer southern
parts of the European continent. The prize was good wages, its
freedom and German culture and language. The American sidewalks
weren't paved with gold and the houses and inustrial complexed were
bombed and razed to the ground by the Allies. So when the work of
reconstructing Germany began, the foreign workers were obliged to
take up jobs that didn't suit their qualifications because there was
a language barrier, and the foreign qualifications were haughtily not
recognised by the German authorities. A colleague of mine was a
dentist from Warsaw (Poland) but had to do the work of an office
secretary. Russian physicians with degrees from Moscow University had
to work as taxi-drivers in NY. Most of the imported manpower was for
the industries, mining, railroad construction, autobahn and the
catering service in hotels and restaurants. Those who managed to save
their money and get additional credits from German banks became
restaurant owners with the help of their families.
A good mmany
first generation families bought or built houses in countries of
their origin such as Turkey, Kurdistan, Italy, Greece but their
grandchildren and children,who grew up in Germany, preferred the
German way of life and generation-conflicts ensued. A house in the
Black Forest or in Hamburg, Munich, Mannheim or Heidelberg was much
prized due to the modern infrastructure, school and college friends,
language, mentality and ,most of all, better job prospects.
To put it
mildly, both Americans and Germans have been lately asking
themselves: 'how many foreigners can we take?'
The rage and
aversion is centered on strangers who can't boast of the Rennaisance
and an all-white genetic code, who were not colonialists but
colonized, and didn't have democracy and pray to another God. It was
no other than Benjamin Franklin who once asked in 1751: 'why should
Palatine Boors be suffered to swarm into our settlements, and, by
herding together, establish their language and manners, to the
exclusion of ours.' Pennsylvania, which was founded by the English,
became a colony of foreigners (Germans) and soon became so numerous
as to Germanize the English settlers, instead of the other way round.
In Germany today there is this fear of being outnumbered and
politically outmanouvred by new citizens from foreign countries.
Xenophobia has always existed everywhere in this world. Perhaps it's
high time to fix immigration and fulfill America's promise as a
nation of immigrants with their own cultural, religious and racial
identity living in an atmosphere of mutual trust and understandig. I
wish Germany and the other EU countries the same.
Kommentare
Kommentar veröffentlichen